TABLE OF CONTENTS



Introduction
A Prayer of Gratitude
Participants
Thankyou to . . .
SUNDAYS
Chapter 1. Sunday Worship
Interlude. On Sunday Clothes
Chapter 2. Church Music
Interlude. Sundays in the 40s
Chapter 3. Sunday School
Interlude. Congregational Childhood: A Reflection
Chapter 4. Bus
CHURCH ACTIVITIES
Chapter 5. Growing up Congregationalists
Chapter 6. Social Justice, Overseas and at Home
Chapter 7. Collins Street Independent
CHURCH
Chapter 8. The Essence of Church
Chapter 9. The Church as Family, the Family and Church
Chapter 10. Ministers' Families
CHURCH GOVERNMENT
Chapter 11. A Discipleship of Equals
Chapter 12. Gathered: The Church Meeting
Chapter 13. Finances
BEING CONGREGATIONAL
Chapter 14. Women in Congregationalism
Chapter 15. The Best Aspects of Being Congregational
Chapter 16. Growth in Faith
Chapter 17. The Qualities of Congregationalists
Chapter 18. Deficiencies and Problems
Chapter 19. Wisdom's Words
Chapter 20. Colours of Congregationalism
Chapter 21. FAQs: Frequently Asked Questions
PEOPLE
Chapter 22. Rubbing Shoulders
Chapter 23. Jim Downing
Chapter 24. Phillip Adams and Gough Whitlam
INTO THE UNITING CHURCH
Chapter 25. Three: Into the Uniting Church
Chapter 26. Church Buildings and Their Loss
AND FINALLY . . .
Chapter 27. The Best
Chapter 28. And a Final Word ...

Next: Introduction

INTRODUCTION




In 1977, most Congregational churches in Australia entered the newly-formed Uniting Church. Nationally, Congregationalists made up 5% of the new church, Methodists 59% and Presbyterians 36%. A small number of Congregational churches opted not to join the Uniting Church; these now form part of the Fellowship of Congregational Churches.

But most people knew that, while they took their Congregational values into the Uniting Church, they were the last people in this country who would call themselves Congregationalists.

Here they tell some of their stories. By doing this I hope that they will prompt former Congregationalists to revisit their memories, and give others just a taste of what life as a Congregationalist in Australia was like.

This is not a history of Australian Congregationalism, and I am not a historian. My interest is in the area of memoir, of story.

*

I had intended that this project would be confined to Victorian Congregationalists. But interstate people sent me such lovely material that I couldn’t bear to leave them out. Most of these stories, however, apply to Victorian Congregationalism.

*

I stated when I began this project that I was seeking former Congregationalists who continued to hold spiritual beliefs. Several of the people who contacted me seemed to fall outside this category. They are listed among the contributors, and only the colour-coding of their folders suggests that they may not be full project participants.

I did not automatically include in this programme those who house asylum seekers or run human development programmes. Neither did I immediately exclude people whose primarily connection with Congregationalism seemed nostalgic, who follow a cult leader, or who have left the ministry, although perhaps I approached their contributions with some caution.

I felt a tolerance towards those who demonstrated a gloating pleasure in what they saw as their Congregational heresy; I once stood in their position, and it was only after theological training that I came to understand that all heresies are inadequate because they belittle God and diminish our humanness, and so they should not be a source of pride.

I excluded one contributor who clearly stated that he was uninterested in worshipping God, while I sympathised with those who found liturgical speech out of touch with contemporary secular language.

I respected the participant who arrived at the conclusion that Christian worship takes place where God’s story and humankind’s story interact, though I felt that his refusal to use the words “the will of God,” when coupled with his determination to find a form of worship which would bring sufficient people into the pews to cover church expenses, suggested that he might be building a secular organization.

I believed in the possibility of reconciling most aspects of post-modernism with faith, but retained my conviction that some such attempts are atheistic, in spite of justifications.

I found exceptional depth of spiritual understanding in three participants, two men and one woman. To my disappointment, I noted that two of these were ordained and that one was a full-time church worker. I maintained my firm Congregational belief in the Priesthood of all Believers but perhaps my unspoken bias towards the laity was somewhat undermined.

Overall, I loved the former Congregationalists who phoned, e-mailed or sent reflections by mail. I found them thoughtful, astute, concerned, and as I remember them from my childhood, people of the greatest integrity. They were creative in the form of their contributions and their kindness and generosity towards me were overwhelming.

*

I was touched that many people seemed so pleased to be asked about our shared Congregational heritage.

I am so glad that I have been able to make a contribution, said one participant. My taking part . . . has given me a chance to unload some of my long-cherished attachment to a church which has been a central part of my life both for spiritual and personal support. This has stood me in great stead throughout the years because in my academic environment I have had to contend with very powerful contrary forces.

*

In its fragmentation, this work reflects my passionate interest in the theological possibilities of post-modernism.

*

I have tried to keep in mind Greg Dening’s advice to writers in ‘Challenges to Perform: History, Passion and the Imagination.’ Unlike me, Dening was a historian, and a very fine one. “Be mysterious,” he said. “The highest ambition of a writer should be to liberate a creative reader. Be experiential, compassionate, entertaining and reforming.”

*

Thankyou to everybody who took part in this project.




Next: A Prayer of Gratitude

Back to index: Index

A PRAYER OF GRATITUDE



Lord of all life and time,
as we begin another day
we remember with gratitude
people both of the present and the past
who have enriched our lives.
Parents, partners, family and friends,
through their wisdom, thoughtfulness
and practical attention,
have nourished and sustained us
through the good times and the tough times.
We bless you for such people.

From Allan Shephard, ed., Prayers on Parade: Prayers and Affirmations for Private or Public Use (Stepney, SA: Axiom 2006) 5.

Next: Participants

Back to index: Index

PARTICIPANTS


Phillip Adams
Elaine Appleton
Ian Baker
Gordon Bate
Nan Bates
Fay Beasley
Doreen Bence
Ken Blackwell
Alex Carter

Roland Cropley
Jim Downing
Shirley Downing
Valda Ferguson
Jan Firth
Keith Gaze
Peggy Goldsmith
Jan Graham
John Gunson

Bill Haining
Shirley Haining
Bruce Hands
Jean Hill
Dawn Hindie
Angas Hurst
Clive Jackson
Len Jackson
Lois Jackson

Merle Jenkins
Isabel Keath
Malcolm Lamont
Nancy Lockley
Barbara Merefield
Peter Munster
Jenny Neil
Lorraine Nelson
Max Nelson

Dawn Odgers
Sylvia Parry
Betty Patrick
Audrey Peacock*
Lois Phillips
Jan Rasche
Flo Rayment
Jack Rayment
Ron Roberts

Alison Sambell
Allan Shephard
Peggy Sperling
Marg Spong
Doreen Stephens
Alf Swan
Bruce Upham
Ted Walker
Margo Watson

John Wheeler*
Stuart Williamson
Colin Wilson
David Wright
Geoff Young

* Continuing Congregationalists

Contributing through Writings

C. Irving Benson. ‘Church & People: Earliest Congregationalists in Port Phillip’ from the Melbourne Herald. 1941 (?).
Maynard Davies. Beyond My Grasp. Sydney: Alpha, 1978.
G. Lindsay Lockley. Congregationalism in Australia. Edited by Bruce Upham. Melbourne: Uniting Church Press, 2001.
Lesslie Newbigin. Preface in James M. Phillips & Robert T Coote, eds, Toward the 21st Century in Christian Mission. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1993.
Albert Peel. The Congregational Two Hundred 1530-1948. London & Southampton: Camelot, 1948.
Ernest J. Price. A Handbook of Congregationalism. London: Independent Press, 1961.
J. Verkuyl. Contemporary Missiology: an Introduction. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1987.




From top: Workshop. Geoff Young, Ali Sambell, Jean Hill, Jan Rasche; Peter Munster; Valda Ferguson; Shirley Haining; Elaine Appleton and friends; Marg Spong; Sylvia Parry; Merle Jenkins; Bill Haining.

Next:
Thankyou to . . .

Back to index: Index

THANKYOU TO . . .


Elaine Appleton in the goldfields, Chewton


Joyce who wouldn’t let me catch a bus
Ron who had cured his asthma
the editors who put me in the magazines
Bill who had read the minutes
Shirley who wanted to call me a taxi
Peter who knew about an olive grove
Geoff who donated petrol and stamps
Allan who had compiled a book of prayers
Frances who had a silver hand
Ian who photocopied a chapter
Margaret who offered to lend her rooms
Malcolm who made a tape
Clive who invited me to join a society
Jean who remembered the Sunday School songs
Jenny who found a recipe
Roland who showed me the organ pipes
Ken who gave me his Congregationalist books
Elaine who showed me the goldfields
Stuart who sang a Sunday School song
Len who showed me his bee-boxes
Sylvia who made soup
Alan who played Welsh choir songs
John who sent me his manuscripts
Marg whose dog was very old
Augustine Uniting Church who invited me to share our story
Jan who had photos of Pilot camps
Gwenda who found a Geoff Barnes booklet
Nancy whose poinsettia had been pruned
David who had photographs of Geelong churches

... and thankyou to everybody else who helped.






From top: Les Appleton, Geoff Young, Roland Cropley



Next: Chapter 1. Sunday Worship

Back to index: Index

SUNDAY WORSHIP

"I am the vine; you are the branches. The one who abides in me will bear much fruit."

Sunday worship took place, in our childhoods, at 11am and 7 pm. Sunday School was at 3 pm, so the day was filled. Later we would experience earlier morning services, Christian Education in conjunction with morning worship and the loss of the evening service.

The basic shape of Divine Worship was what has been called the Protestant hymn sandwich, with hymns chosen from Congregational Praise. An order of service for the Burwood-Surrey Hill Parish service, held at Wyclif Congregational Church in 1975 had the following form:

Invocation and response.
A moment of meditation.
Hymn.
Scripture readings, with the verses of the psalm read alternately by minister and people.
Prayers and Lord’s Prayer.
Hymn.
Offering and the prayer of dedication of ourselves and our gifts.
Hymn.
Sermon.
Hymn.
Blessing and threefold amen.

At the start of worship, the choir entered from the choir vestry and sat in the seats which were elevated on our right. The women sat in the two front seats with the men behind. Naturally, there were more women choir members than men. By this time most members of the congregation were seated, and only the door stewards were standing in each porch with hymn-books in their hands ready to greet the last-minute arrivals.

The minister entered from the ministers’ vestry above us. He slipped into the pulpit which was placed in front of the organ pipes, raised above the communion table and organ console. We did not stand as he entered. He conducted the whole service from the pulpit, unless there was a baptism or communion service. Usually he wore an academic gown over his suit, and a shirt and tie. Occasionally a minister wore a clerical collar or the two white tabs more often associated with Presbyterian ministers. Stoles were not worn at that time.

We stood for the hymns, and bowed our heads, seated, for the prayers. We used the traditional form of the Lord’s Prayer, “Thy kingdom come,” and ended the prayer, as other Protestants did, with the words “For thine is the kingdom, the power and the glory, for ever and ever, Amen.” The benediction, the final blessing, usually took the form “May the blessing of God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, be with us now and evermore.” We sang the threefold amen, “A-men, a-men, a-a-a-a-men.”

Participants had clear memories of Sunday worship:

Before church. Golden pews. Ledges where books are placed. I look from the left to the centre. Each pew has familiar faces, people choosing the same seats weekly. The stained-glass windows reflect red and golden light. Communion table, bronze vases, flower arrangements. Organ pipes, towering above. Collection plates in the front. Christening font in golden wood. Plaques in memory of lost soldiers and worthy church members, carpeted floors. Rustling, murmuring, clinking of coins. Soft organ music.

*

I’m taking my shoe off so I can toast the sole of my foot on the heated pipe under the seat in front ... I remember the organist sliding along the organ seat to unobtrusively go and sit in the front end row of the choir stalls for the sermon.

*

When I think of Wyclif, I think even now of the gold, gothic words, ‘O Worship the Lord in the Beauty of Holiness.’ As a child, I sat week by week and made up games like how many other words I could make out of the letters in these words. I did the same with the numbers in the hymns, this time adding and subtracting.

*

“DRAW NEAR WITH FAITH”: THE SERVICE OF HOLY COMMUNION, OR THE LORD’S SUPPER

I read the words of the Invitation to Holy Communion from a 1975 order of service, and my heart turned over.

“You who truly and earnestly repent of your sins and are in love and fellowship with your neighbours, and intend to lead a new life, following the commandments of God and walking from henceforth in His holy ways; draw near with faith, and take this Holy Sacrament to your comfort . . . ” they began.

Memories of the Communion Service rushed back, the table with its starched and beautifully-ironed white linen cloth, silver plates with small cubes of stale white bread, tiny glasses of unfermented grape juice on trays which stacked on top of each other (with difficulty) as they were returned, the quiet reverence of the deacons who served us in our pews.

Participants had similar memories.

I remember the communion services, the ribbons on the end of every second pew. In the last verse of the final hymn we used to move to the communion pews so that the servers with the beautiful wooden trays could move along the space. I’ve never seen it done that way anywhere else, but it was such a sensible way to serve. The grape juice was very sweet, but it never occurred to me that there could be anything different.

I remembered the words of the Institution of the Sacrament: “On the night when he was betrayed Jesus took bread and blessed it and broke it and said, ‘Take this, all of you, this is my body which is broken for you . . . Do this to remember me.’ ”

As Protestant members of the Catholic/Protestant divide, Congregational children imagined that Catholics believed that the bread and wine actually became the body and blood of Christ, and were scandalized by what we saw as a degraded belief. In practice of course, enlightened Catholics avoided literalism and many read “May it become for us the body and blood . . .” as a statement about profound meaning. The essential difference however remained. As Congregationalists we remembered through Holy Communion; Catholics were fed. As Congregationalists we saw Holy Communion as “an outward and visible sign of an inward and spiritual grace.” Catholics saw the Eucharist as a symbol with efficacy.

One participant retained a small boy’s memory of communion:

Grape juice turns into wine if it is not thrown out. There were lots of half-bottles of grape-juice out in the vestry. I don’t think we drank them, but we used to take the tops off and smell them.

*

SPECIAL SERVICES: HARVEST THANKSGIVING AND WATCH-NIGHT SERVICES

Harvest thanksgiving remained in the minds of participants, probably because with hindsight it was seen as an inappropriate carry-over from rural England. The church was decorated with vegetables, honey, jam and fruit. We sang “We plough the fields and scatter/ The good seed on the land/ But it is fed and watered/ By God’s almighty hand” but none of us actually did. This was suburban Melbourne, and most of our fathers worked in town.

One participant stated:

We had an annual Harvest Festival. But it faded out and stopped altogether, perhaps when everyone brought packets of cornflakes instead of pumpkins and marrows. My sister remembered setting up the display of food on the floor of the communion dais. Someone had places strings of onions up the pillars, but they were told to take them down. It wasn’t considered suitable to festoon the church with vegetables.

At Williamstown, a New Years’ Eve Watch Night service was held each year until after the inauguration of the Uniting Church. Bill stated: It was a service that attracted many once-a-year attendees, . . . between 60 and 120. It was also the night when the law was broken, because we rang a bell at midnight; only on one occasion that I can recall did anyone make a protest about the noise.


WEDDINGS, CHRISTENINGS AND FUNERALS

I think of Jack and me on our wedding day, the Christening of our children, and my mother’s funeral, happy times and sad, said one participant, reminding us of the Church’s role in providing rites of passage.

Baptism was not a word used in Congregational Churches. We christened our babies, made them Christ’s, and I regret the lost of that old, lovely word. Early in my life, babies were often christened in a quiet family group on a Sunday afternoon. Later, christenings took place during morning worship, the baby held in the minister’s arms as water from the font was touched on her forehead, and she was named. One Wyclif minister, having given a baby the wrong name once, always said to the parents, “Name this child.” Ministers tried to make sure that the baby did not cry, and tended to hastily hand the baby back to a parent if her face crumpled.

At funerals, coffins were always closed, and increasingly, absent, as thanksgiving services for life gained popularity. We all attended funerals in support of our fellow worshippers.

And weddings? They were like old-fashioned weddings everywhere. We promised fidelity for a lifetime, for better for worse, for richer for poorer, to love and to cherish till death did us part. No home-made vows for Congregationalists. Some of us married fellow-Congregationalists and many of us have stayed married.






*

One participant summed up Congregational worship. Music and preaching were his focus:

The formal worship in the Congregational and Uniting Church suits my taste - I find great comfort and inspiration in many of the great hymns (although there are plenty both ancient and modern which are either banal or meaningless) and more of the sermons than not are well worth listening to. I'm not a very prayerful person nor particularly wrapped up in formal ceremony, so the 'old-fashioned' services suit me very well but plenty of other people want something quite different, and that can mean different scenes in different places. One shape does not fit everybody.

*

Another stated:

Our services were structured, dignified and reverent but we were not a liturgical church. We observed the sacraments. I have treasured the Spirit-filled church families with whom I have worshipped.


Next: Interlude. On Sunday Clothes

Back to index: Index

INTERLUDE: ON SUNDAY CLOTHES

Sunday School anniversaries were held in the spring. Every year, little Congregational girls had a new summer dress.

As Congregationalists we wore church clothes to church, said one woman. “Sunday best” was a phrase generally used at the time.

Like women everywhere, participants looked back at events, and knew what they were wearing.

I remember singing my first solo wearing my new anniversary outfit, a summer dress trimmed with pale yellow ribbons with matching straw hat, said one.

Others continued the theme.

A pale blue robia voile dress, handmade by my mother on her Singer treadle sewing machine, because it was only a few years after the war, and there are still many scarcities. Besides, good mothers made their children’s clothes.

*

Shoes? said one woman. I can’t exactly picture them, but I know we went to the city to buy new shoes and had our feet x-rayed.

*

We had a new best dress for the anniversary, our new dress for the year. One year mine was a pale green and white check in some soft material, with puffed sleeves piped in white, a white collar, and a sash which was sewn on at the sides and tied at the back. I loved that dress. It was not made by my mother, because my aunt was a professional dressmaker, a very good one; she sewed it on the treadle sewing machine that she used all her life, said another. A big hair-ribbon tied in a bow, with the hair gathered to the side. A side parting, and bobby pins. The boys wore grey short trousers and v-necked knitted pullovers.

*

Another said, I remember Christine at the Sunday School anniversary wearing something beautiful. I wished and wished I had one. It wasn’t a cardigan, it had short sleeves. A bolero. Yes, and it was made out of probably mohair, incredibly soft. Angora? That’s right. It was pale yellow and it was so beautiful ...

A new dress for the anniversary? Oh yes. Every year. My sister and I used to have the same design in different material. One had the most extraordinary collar, like a rectangle with a circle in the centre for the head, a sailor collar. And with a white band all around the edge. Cotton, floral, with deep pink and mauve flowers. My sister’s was pale yellow and green. And on our feet black patent leather shoes with a strap, just for Sundays. We cleaned them with cream in a jar. And white socks turned over at the top. On Saturday night my mother put my hair in rags to make Shirley Temple curls and it was tied back. With ribbons? Of course. Satin and about an inch wide.

*

Our best grey shorts, said a man. A plain open-necked sports shirt, probably white, and a pullover if it was cold. Our best clothes, clean and tidy. Long socks, black shoes. Alf conducted dress inspection. “Pull your socks up, boy,” he’d say as we started to climb up the platform at the Sunday School anniversary.

*



Next: Chapter 2. Church Music

Back to index: Index

CHURCH MUSIC




The core of Congregational church music was hymn singing from Congregational Praise, accompanied by the pipe organ and the choir.

Participants hummed tunes and sang verses of hymns at interview, and they copied out words.

Even people with severe dementia continue to respond to music, and can sometimes join in the words of a song when other verbal skills are lost. Clearly sacred music connects our deepest selves with God.

*

HYMNS

Isaac Watts (1674–1748) was the great Congregationalist hymn-writer, the equivalent of Methodism’s Charles Wesley. His most loved hymns are probably ‘All People that on Earth Do Dwell’ (#1, Congregational Praise), ‘When I Survey the Wondrous Cross’ (#131 CP), ‘Jesus Shall Reign Where’er the Sun’ (#158 CP), ‘How Pleased and Blest Was I’ (#238 CP) and ‘Joy to the World’ (#224 Australian Hymn Book). Congregational Praise contained forty-eight Watts hymns and The Australian Hymn Book of 1977, produced for the Uniting Church, contained thirty-six. The hymns in Congregational Praise were more acceptable to me than Charles Wesley’s. Isaac Watts’ hymns had a depth of words, said one musically-trained participant.

With the exception of Sunday School songs, the hymn most often quoted by participants was ‘We limit not the truth of God to our poor reach of mind’, number 230 in Congregational Praise. The tune is Ellacombe and the words are by George Rawson (1807-89), based on the parting words of Pastor John Robinson to the Pilgrim Fathers as they left the Netherlands for America in 1620.

Undoubtedly several factors came together in this choice. The hymn was linked with our proudest moment in Congregational history, the Pilgrim Fathers’ journey in the Mayflower. The concept of looking for a new and better hope reached beyond the New World to the Kingdom, the New Jerusalem. And the words of the chorus, “The Lord hath yet more light and truth / To break forth from his word” epitomized the confidence which Congregationalists felt in the guidance of the Holy Spirit through the Church Meeting as we journeyed in faith.

It can be said that you can tell a former Congregationalist by her confidence in dealing with the lovely archaic work “darkling,” which we met only in this hymn. We were perfectly able to discern its meaning from context, and shuddered when the editors of The Australian Hymn Book changed it to “groping” with its unpleasant connotations. The editors of Together in Song changed the word again, to “searching,” but they lost the echoes of moving forward in the dark which the older word used to have.

Here are the original words of the hymn:

We limit not the truth of God
To our poor reach of mind,
By notions of our day and sect,
Crude, partial and confined:
No, let a new and better hope
Within our hearts be stirred:
The Lord hath yet more light and truth
To break forth from His word.

Darkling our great forefathers went
The first steps of the way;
‘Twas but the dawning, yet to grow
Into the perfect day.
And grow it shall, our glorious sun
More fervid rays afford:
The Lord hath yet more light and truth
To break forth from His word.

The valleys past, ascending still,
Our souls would higher climb,
And look down from supernal heights
On all the bygone time.
Upward we press, the air is clear,
And the sphere-music heard:
The Lord hath yet more light and truth
To break forth from His word.

O Father, Son and Spirit, send
Us increase from above;
Enlarge, expand all Christian souls
To comprehend Thy love;
And make us all go on to know,
With nobler powers conferred,
The Lord hath yet more light and truth
To break forth from His word.

*

A single hymn verse was sung in several churches as introit and was fondly remembered:

I remember the introit, a verse from John Greenleaf Whittier’s lovely, ‘Dear Lord and Father of Mankind.’ It was verse 5:

Drop thy still dews of quietness,
Till all our strivings cease.
Take from our souls the strain and stress,
And let our ordered lives confess
The beauty of Thy peace.

I clearly recall repeatedly noticing a change in my family sitting alongside me, occurring during the singing, corporately, of these words. And I liked the peace that came, and valued it then as now,
said one participant.

Other hymns sung each week have also stayed in people's minds:

At Black Rock, No. 274 in Congregational Praise, “Jesus stand among us / In Thy risen power. / Let this time of worship / Be a hallowed hour” was sung every Sunday night as an introit, said one participant.

One participant remembered ‘To Be a Pilgrim’ (‘Who Would True Valour See’), ‘The God of Abraham Praise’, ‘Jesus Calls Us O’er the Tumult’, ‘All Things Bright and Beautiful’ and the Twenty-Third Psalm.

We used to have a children’s address and sing a children’s hymn in church,said another. The children’s hymns were lovely: ‘God make my life a little light / Within the world to glow.’

However, some of the old Congregational hymns are now a problem. One participant explained:

I have heard young people say “We can’t stand up and sing these old hymns.” I hear this and understand this. Music is life-giving. I like Together in Song, and feel much affection for the hymns in Congregational Praise but I am not able to sing some of them now theologically; I find it hard to sing hymns totally looking at God as Father. Many older hymns are tied up with 18th century religious attitudes.

The Servant Song is strong in my psyche. Not to be ministered to but to minister. “Will you let me be your servant, / Let me be as Christ to you; / Pray that I may have the grace to / Let you be my servant, too.” Since the Uniting Church came into being, TaizĂ© music has become important for me, TaizĂ© used as prayer.


And in the Uniting Church some participants still miss the Congregational tunes:

We sing different tunes to the familiar words and somehow it doesn’t seem the same. Lillian and Henry Wells were great musicians. Lillian was organist at Pitt Street and Henry was on the committee to chose hymns for the Australian Hymn Book. As we stand to sing the hymn, I say to him, “Henry, why did you let them give us this other tune?” In my mind of course. I’ve never met the man. I’ve still got my Congregational Praise.

*

METRICAL PSALMS

These were remembered too.

And of course the regular-as-clockwork sung Psalm or Canticle, like ‘Be Ye Lifted Up, Ye Ancient Doors’ from Congregational Praise. These Psalms or Canticles, all from the Old Testament, were harmonised, and although sometimes a little dirge-like if in a minor key, were always a feature, renewing spiritual respect for the ancient Jewish roots of Christianity. They were so clearly sung that I could understand all the words, said one man.

*

GRACE BEFORE MEALS

Remember sung grace? said one participant. At camps and Sunday School picnics?

The doxology, “Praise God from whom all blessings flow. / Praise Him all creatures here below. / Praise Him above, ye heavenly host. / Praise Father, Son and Holy Ghost.” And, to the same tune, “Be present at our table, Lord. / Be there and everywhere adored. / These blessings give and grant that we / May feast in Paradise with Thee.”


I don’t think we’re allowed to feast in Paradise now, said another. I think the last line has been changed to “May live in fellowship with thee.” When I think of feasting in Paradise, she went on, I picture Home Mission Teas and long tables with white cloths. I think that that is my only image of the Church eating a meal together at a table.

*

THE CHOIR

I remember myself aged 10 years—Sunday School anniversary—standing on the tiered platform singing the lovely songs set to classical tunes from a book called Jubilate, accompanied by piano and two violins, said one participant.

The value of this experience has been immeasurable. I have sung many solos since the age of 10, the last being soon after my 80th birthday, and I am still singing in our church choir. It was also my introduction to musical appreciation.

Music. Many of our hymn tunes were unique. I miss them! We were blessed with good musicians, organists and choir leaders.

*

Alf Swan spoke of music:

I am picturing myself at age sixteen in 1943, as a member of the Wyclif Congregational church choir. Next to me is the leading bass, Ewart Phillips, my mentor. We are practising under the leadership of Mrs Ekins for the forthcoming inter-church choral competitions. The choir trophy cabinet already holds several cups and we are anxious to add to the collection.

I was learning to sing and read the bass line at this time. I was also learning to play the pipe organ and piano under the guidance of my mother, a proficient accompanist who had achieved some success in at South Street Ballarat eisteddfods.

My father, Rev E.F.W.Swan, was minister at this time and always led the choir in prayer before we took our seats in the choir stalls.

From where I sat each Sunday, I would look across at the stained glass window donated in memory of Mrs Ekins’ husband who was killed in an airship disaster in the 1930s.

Now in my eighties and still a member of the local church choir, I realize that this was the beginning of a life-long love of singing and playing the great Christian hymns and anthems.


*

I had placed a Memorial Window in City Church in memory of my husband, so I transferred it to Bardon Church, said another participant. This beautiful window depicting our musical family, now stands behind the Communion Table. I was a singer in my younger days, and was a member of the City Church Choir from the age of 16 onwards. My husband Neville, was a gifted violinist, and often accompanied the choir when singing anthems. My son Greg, and daughter Glenys, were also members of the choir. This was brought to a close when Neville contacted cancer, and died as the age of 46 years. A total shock to everyone who knew him.

*
ORGAN

At 14 I came to Augustine Congregational where my father was organist, said one man, and I have been here ever since. An interest in music and the organ was my primary motivator. I played the church organ at 14 after church and then went home for my roast dinner. And I kept on doing that. At 30 I extricated myself from IBM and became a full-time music student at Melbourne University. For most of my life I have been involved in music making, and from 1984 to 2002 I have sung in the Victoria State Opera or Opera Australia choruses and been paid for the work.

*
As organist I had complete autonomy, said another participant. Of course the minister always chooses the hymns, but what the choir sang and the organ music which was used was in my hands. At Geelong we had a small congregation and a small choir; they were very supportive.

My favourite Congregational hymn? The tune is Penlan. Number 412 in Congregational Praise. I don’t remember the words. Yes, it’s come to me. “In heavenly love abiding.” Another is “Fight the good fight with all thy might.”

The old church had a pipe organ, and the new church had a Wurlitzer. In between I played the piano for our worship in the hall.

For many years I played the organ without pay. Then I was paid a small amount. I wasn’t on a huge salary then, and that helped. I charged $100 to pay for weddings though. Most of the money went back into the plate. It’s a matter of courtesy to ask the church organist to play for a wedding. Now I’m on a good salary so I don’t take any money. I’m 66 years old and I’ve played the organ for 50 years.

The music which was played while communion was distributed had meaning. Often I played hymns with the tenor part brought out, hymns like ‘The King of Love my shepherd is.’ I played ‘Dear Lord and Father of Mankind’ and ‘At Even E’er the Sun was Set’. There was a companion to the Congregational hymnbook which explained each hymn. I played Bach a lot; in Bach every part has its own melody. The eight little preludes and fugues of Bach are the foundation of all organists. And Handel, Handel’s Messiah. Contrapuntal music is so challenging and uplifting.

*



Next: Interlude. Sundays in the 40s

Back to index: Index

INTERLUDE: CONGREGATIONAL CHILDHOOD- A REFLECTION

The church was opposite a park, and in the park were giant guns. We slid down them after church when our parents were talking, and poked lolly papers up the barrels.

Guns in a pleasant suburban park. The re-inscription of a war-trope through context? Spears into pruning-hooks? A relocation which signalled the end of wars? A salutary reminder of the fate which awaited humankind if we did not learn to “study war no more?” Or a mindless war souvenir? One thing is certain, a Freudian interpretation of the cannon seems very far from this scene.

Birthday song. Children singing to other children and naming them as “little child so dear”? A sentimentalized view of childhood filtered through adult sensibilities.

Missions, unquestioned. Now through knowledge of the Stolen Generation I cringe to remember our unthinking, colonial certainties.

Children safe and unsexualised, dependent. Time to grow up. Protected.

*




Next: Chapter 4. Bus


Back to index: Index

INTERLUDE: SUNDAYS IN THE 1940’S



A woman participant remembered her childhood:

Sundays were almost entirely taken up with worshipping then, but this was not seen as a chore. There was a lunch-time roast dinner ritual, because the dinner could be put in the oven before the family left for church. My mother was in the choir, often singing a solo. When we arrived home she organised dinner too, but there was no complaint.

In the afternoon there was Sunday School, and there was another service at 7 at night. After 1947 when their first car arrived from England, the family often went for a small drive on Sunday afternoons.

I was never allowed to knit on Sundays, until one wet afternoon I was driving everyone mad and was told by her mother to get my wool and needles, but not to tell my father.

It was good enough for my mother to get meals, but my parents didn’t buy from the milk-bar on that day. People valued their day off; if they bought from the milk-bar, someone else couldn’t have that time of leisure.


*



Next: Chapter 3. Sunday School

Back to index: Index

SUNDAY SCHOOL


Chewton Congregational Church Sunday School, probably in the 1950’s.


A woman contributor spoke:

I have been remembering Sunday school; I return to this chilly morning from a warm and shadow-free place in my soul. Oh, those picnics, where I recall nothing but sun and excitement and the anniversary, (three services). I went to lunch at your home. We ate bottled cherries and played “Tinker, Tailor” with the stones. You came to my home for tea. I remember after the afternoon “performance” playing in our back-yard, holding buttercups to our chins. How slowly the day passed with that thrill of expectancy in performing within us. The platform with the green baize steps, where each year we progressed higher. The fidgeting of the feet of some of the boys who were possibly dreaming of riding bikes or kicking the footy; the adrenalin rush and nervous giggling when we entered the church and the acclaim when we left. Alas, not a photo was taken of those days but the images remain etched within as does the atmosphere, the sense of belonging, contributing and being valued. So much to remember and it takes only a single image for me to be overwhelmed with the torrent of memories. Our naughtiness in our Sunday School classes, based on the knowledge that we were firmly part of a wide family.

Congregationalists attended Sunday School on Sunday afternoons at first, and later during church time on Sunday mornings. In my case the superintendent was one of Australia’s most distinguished publishers; my teachers were usually pretty young woman in the process of getting engaged, often to young men from the church.

In adulthood, I know the bible stories, (though Daniel in the lion’s den, Noah and the ark and the crucifixion of Jesus Christ held an equal place in my mind until adulthood and theology training gave them a context). I recently found, while sitting in a cafĂ© with a former Congregationalist, that we could both still recite a psalm which we learned for the annual scripture exams in the words of the King James version. What I learned has been with me always, said one participant.

Maynard Davies wrote in Beyond My Grasp of the fear felt by him and his friends during a polio epidemic. The possibility of death and paralysis did not alarm them, but they were terrified that the Sunday School picnic might be cancelled. Participants had similar priorities; picnics and anniversaries dominated their recollections.

Kindergarten

In Sunday School Kindergarten “Hear the Pennies Dropping,” and “Do You See this Penny” were well-remembered songs, and with these words, the collection has stayed in people’s minds.

Even though we usually only had a penny or a halfpenny to put in, my brother and I always put something in the coconut collection plate in the Junior Sunday School. I can remember walking around the circle with the coconut, taking up the collection, said one participant.

Several Sunday Schools had a special birthday chair, where a child sat while everyone sang
Happy birthday, happy birthday,
Little child so dear.
May the Loving Father keep you
All the coming year.

I have the kindergarten birthday chair at home,
said one participant. When the church building was sold at union, I asked if I could have it.

Leaving with a coloured text as we walked out the door, said another.

When the Chewton kids picked up the mail,
said a third, Mr Docking’s parcel used to contain the ‘Sunday School Scholar’ pamphlets. These were handed out each week. We used to set up scenes in the sand tray. There were lead figures and palm trees.

As we left we sang,
Our Sunday School is over,
And we are going home.
'Goodbye, goodbye,
Be always kind and true.’
‘Goodbye, Goodbye,
We will be kind and true,’
said one man, singing the third and fourth lines as tenor and the last two in falsetto.

New babies born into the church were added to the cradle roll in Kindergarten, and a song was sung then too:
Our baby’s name is on the roll
We love to see it there.
Dah dum, dah dum, dah dum, dah dum,
In God’s loving care
are the remembered words.

Teachers remembered too:

When we were first married, we were co-opted to help by teaching a Sunday School class on Sunday afternoons. I can see us now, sitting on tiny chairs in a circle with all the children. One pugnacious little boy offered to punch Jack on the nose if he came near me.

Scripture exams

Each year we had to learn a Bible passage by heart. The Young People’s Department of the Congregational Union held a rally at Collins Street church on a Friday evening in October, where prizes of books and certificates were awarded for the children with the best marks in the annual scripture exams. The Sunday schools sat together in blocks; Duncan Reeves, the YPD director before Len Forward, conducted the service; he and Gwladys Barker helped to seat the children. There was a speaker, usually an LMS missionary home on furlough. Wyclif went to the city by van. A shield was presented to the Sunday School that had the highest aggregate, a wooden shield, with small engraved metal shields stating the winner for the year. Because Wyclif had the most small shields, we presented a second wooden shield when the first was full.


The book prizes were remembered, and some were retained:

I won at the exam, but I got a very small book. Mr Docking bought a larger one and gave it to me as well, said one woman.

I found a book I received in 1951 (aged 7) for getting 95% at the exam, said another. They started young, didn’t they. It has the coloured plate stuck inside. One of the stories is about Sambo and Topsy, a tad politically incorrect these days, and compared with children’s books today, quite uninspiring and pedestrian. Studying for exams— (can you believe it?????)—I can still quote “Consider the lilies of the field . . .” I still recall one of my prizes. I loved it, Gull’s Point and Pineapples.

Sunday School anniversaries

In our heyday we had five services, over two Sundays, and a concert mid-week,
said one participant. Hymns were rehearsed for weeks before at Sunday School, and then we trooped into church and climbed a tiered platform erected each year by the church handyman. Another man worked the slide projector at the back of the church.

My cousin and I were hand-picked to take up the collection at one of the Sunday School anniversary services. Other people did the sides, but the middle was much harder, as the plates sometimes went right along, and were sometimes passed back. We worked out a wonderful sequence. But old Mr. Dower passed the plate the wrong way and ruined the whole thing. I can still see my cousin’s face,
said another woman.

Sunday School picnic

The picnic was held once a year. The Sunday School trooped off on a Saturday, or on Cup Day, on forms in a furniture van or by train.

The picnic? said one participant. Always warm. Van with hard seats, songs sung, ‘Quartermaster’s store.’ Travelling miles and miles. Raspberry cordial, sandwiches, grapes. Three-legged races, egg and spoon. Parents arriving at their leisure to sit on chairs or on rugs.

*

I used to get car-sick, so getting into the van, I was never sure that I would make it, said another. It was great fun being all in together. We sang ‘Ten Green Bottles’ and songs like that. We learned songs that we wouldn’t have learned anywhere else and passed them on to the younger children.

One year for the picnic there were new skirts for my sisters and for me. I was so excited about that skirt. I used to enjoy the races—not the three-legged because that hurt—the running races because I used to win.

There were drinks on the table and food, and we could help ourselves, come and take what we wanted. I can see the women in the kitchen making sandwiches. Other people used different fillings, egg, tomato and mock chicken. There were cakes and grapes on a tray; there was raspberry cordial. We went to Kalorama, and to Wattle Glen.


*

From Chewton we went to Malmsbury for the Sunday School picnic. When we arrived we ate a yeast bun. Later we had a pasty, which was always called a paste-ee, said a man.

We took our own mugs. I used to win the three-legged race. We always had raspberry vinegar to drink. They bought Brooks’ Cordial Extract in a 200 ml bottle with a red wax seal. This was poured into a jug with water and sugar.
We had ham sandwiches with dry mustard, and that used to make me sick.


*

Church picnics were held at Queenscliff. We travelled there by train. There were races for the kids and raspberry cordial to drink. We sat on deckchairs in the shade and people swam, said another man.

Bible Class

Interestingly, senior Sunday School has vanished from people’s memory, except for a woman who read the cricket club honours board while the superintendent’s bald head shone during a very long prayer. But Bible Class, the most senior level of Sunday School, was well remembered:

Bible study (after we were too old for Sunday School) was open to fresh ideas, and material was examined in the setting of the times it was written, said one participant.

*

My parents took the Bible Class for a while, said another. A pilot used to “buzz” the tennis courts on Sunday afternoon to distract the Bible Class members. He was well-known in Surrey Hills. My parents had “control problems” when he flew overhead and couldn’t really get the class to concentrate after that.

*



Next: Interlude. Congregational Childhood: A Reflection

Back to index: Index

BUS



I kept hearing about buses being used to start Sunday Schools in Melbourne’s Eastern suburbs, but I couldn’t work out how many buses there had been.

I asked one participant about this and she replied,
The bus? I think there was only one. Johnny Harper bought it from a camp. When he tried to drive it back to Blackburn South, he discovered it didn’t have any brakes.

Here are a couple of bus stories.


*


Having attended both Presbyterian and Methodist Sunday Schools, my first contact with Congregationalists came when the Rev Doug Riley from Kew Congregational Church set up an outreach Sunday School on the block behind my home on the second highest hill in Melbourne [near the Balwyn/North Balwyn border]. He arrived in an old tramways bus, complete with seating and a little organ. Very few children to start with, but the area started to go ahead- we had shifted there in 1946, and the ‘Bus’ appeared-I think- early 1950. I believe I was still 13 when I was asked to play the organ for the singing, and to help in other ways.


*


In the early 1950s I was a member of the Congregational Youth Fellowship at North Balwyn. We became involved in an outreach programme which used a rather elderly bus which we drove each week to a site in East Doncaster where we conducted a Sunday School and (I think) a monthly church service. The bus was of the old type with seats around the perimeter so it worked out quite well, I do not know how long this all lasted but certainly there was no Congregational Church in East Doncaster by the late 1950s.

Elsa and I married in 1957 and during that year I applied for every school in the metropolitan area as Elsa was still nursing in the city. I was appointed to Forest Hill Primary School in the 3rd term—and had to look up a map to find it! After we moved into the area in 1958 we decided to attend the nearest Congregational Church and found it was in Charlotte Street, South Blackburn. We found that the services were being conducted in the old bus, now parked permanently on the South Blackburn site. Within a couple of years an all-purpose hall was built on the site and a very faithful church community developed.

*



Next: Chapter 5. Growing up Congregationalist

Back to index: Index

GROWING UP CONGREGATIONALISTS: PILOTS, CYF, CONCERTS, FAIRS AND SPORT




Many former Congregationalists especially remembered the church’s social activities. They singled out Pilots and CYF, concerts and plays, fairs, fancy dress, cricket and tennis as part of their special memories.


PILOTS

Pilots was a youth group for children aged from 8 to 12. Congregationalism’s answer to scouts and guides, the club was based on the structure of the navy.

Children met weekly in watches under Watch Leaders who reported to the Captain, for games, worship, and to work towards badges similar to those won by scouts.

The uniform was flexible; girls wore white blouses and navy skirts of different designs and navy berets. But Victoria’s Chief Pilot, youth worker John Ward, was resplendent in gold braid.

One former Pilot remembered:

Pilots extended what the wider church was giving to me in a practical way. It was like scouts. There were badges to do. Remember the Pilot’s Ticket, that exam? We only sat it twice. It was really hard. I just didn’t know the answers, so I wrote down what seemed sensible. I remember going to Prahran Congregational Church. John Ward, Chief Pilot, was there in his regalia; he was barking orders. They said they were going to present the certificate. Only one person had passed in the whole of Victoria. Then they said my name. I sat there, stunned; I couldn’t move. Uncle Keith said, ‘Well, go on.’ I’ve still got the certificate, among my precious possessions. I suppose that I was eight.

Doing badges. Learning knots. The reef knot has stayed with me the whole time, invaluable, because if it’s tied properly it won’t come undone. Flags. The Blue Peter. The uniform, the scarf, the Pilot badges. And the badges for levels too: Acting Able Seaman, Able Seaman, Midshipman.

Being a watch leader, and learning to look after others in the watch. Pilot Sports’ Day. The Pilot prayer: ‘Teach us Good Lord to serve Thee as Thou deservest. To give and not to count the cost. To fight and not to heed the wounds. To labour and not to ask for any reward, save that of knowing that we do Thy will.’ In the 1990’s someone used that prayer in a church service and it all came flooding back.

Pilot camps were held in the hall of country churches during May school holidays.

Going as trainee leader. Up to Kyneton and the Leaders’ Room with its big fireplace and big fire. Another fire in the extension to the dining-room. Giving people responsibility, learning to lead. Having that confidence given to you that you are ok to have this position. Bunk beds like cyclone gates and hessian palliasses filled with straw. I used to play the organ in the break, probably the same thing over and over again.

At Pilot camps we had a quiet time. Our own time to be with ourselves. We could read, or lie down, or sit on the bed. We could sleep. It may have been John Ward’s idea. He was a teacher-librarian. I remember the stories he used to read us. Inside the smaller room. Not the big dining-room. It could have been the room that became the leaders’ room. He told us that every time there was a rude word, he’d say ‘jolly.’ They all kept coming out. Once there was a ‘jolly jolly.’ He was a great story-teller or reader. He had a good sense about kids and how far they would go, about who was likely to push the boundaries. I think that now; at the time things just happened as they were supposed to.




Pilot camp, Kyneton 1956. Top: Rev Alf Blake, Camp Mother Jan Clack, Chief Pilot John Ward. Below: pilots

*

CYF: CONGREGATIONAL YOUTH FELLOWSHIP





From Pilots, young Congregationalists went on to the Congregational Youth Fellowship, Junior and Senior CYF. Many Congregationalist met their future marriage partners there.

I grew up in the Black Rock Church and became a member of the Congregational Youth Fellowship, eventually becoming State Secretary. I remember the Rev. Roy Alexander coming to Black Rock to speak to the C.Y.F. and then staying on into the late hours discussing the first two chapters of Genesis, explaining that these were Hebrew creation myths, not scientific accounts. This was the beginning of a healthy scepticism about the traditional teachings of Christianity.

*

After I turned 15, I was invited to attend the Kew CYF, and regularly attended the Youth Group, helped in the Sunday School in the mornings, and attended church services in the evening. As a very shy person, I was horrified to be elected ‘welcomer of new people’ in my second year of attending CYF. I later discovered—of course—that that was a new role that Doug Riley had specially tailored for my needs. I was well-accepted by the young people there, and became involved in the tennis teams, badminton, monthly dances, outings, study groups, participation in services etc. We all felt like part of the church family.

*

There were four churches in the Castlemaine circuit, Castlemaine, Walmer, Chewton and Maldon. Walmer is in dairy country. They had an old copper there, and they used to fill it up with milk, and throw in a handful of ground coffee. I can smell it now. They supplied dairy country food too, cream puffs and cream cakes for supper.

*

We waxed the floor for CYF dances. We’d tacked carpet onto a box, weighted it down with bricks and added ropes. We shaved candles onto the floor and pulled the box about. One year we decorated the hall for the Cup Eve dance on Saturday. The Sunday School superintendent didn’t like teaching in a hall decorated with streamers and horses.

*

One of the activities we had about 1950 with the Chewton Youth Club was a paper-trail hike, always held on moonlight nights. The treat at the end was always saveloys cooked on an open fire in an old kerosene tin, with a loaf of bread normally. We often cooked potatoes in the coals; they were quite a treat. There was one rule: no pairing off into the scrub.

*

Len Forward, Director of CYF in Victoria, had a station-wagon and formed the CYF Flying Squad. I and others went to rural churches like Wahgunyah to take ideas for CYF programmes. Len Forward was enthusiastic that young people should have a strong role in the church.

*




The highlight of CYF for most participants was Easter Camp.

At an Easter camp at Bendigo, a man from Croydon took the evening devotion leading out of Easter. As we left in silence, we walked through the beam of a projector, which threw our shadows onto the back wall. We seemed to be walking away from the cross.

Then, under a starlit sky, Syd Henshall took the evening devotion, reading from The Unknown Disciple. I thought, ‘How could you not believe?’

*

CONCERTS AND PLAYS

I remember Thursday evening rehearsals of one-act plays. Ena Sambell directing, wigs, furniture gathered from all and sundry, the red velvet curtains, the musty hall filled with appreciative audience. One year we put on The Mikado. Another year we did Ten Sixty-Six and All That. Most of the Church was in it.

*

I have fond memories of the original weatherboard church with its stage for concerts—boys dressed in tutus and gumboots ‘dancing’ Swan Lake . . .

*

FAIRS

Our church held an annual fair in the hall, and each organization was responsible for a decorated stall. There was the white elephant stall, jams and cakes, hand-knitted garments, books, and plants. Someone set up a trampoline behind the church. There were competitions too. I remember trying to guess which childhood photo belonged to which senior church member, and children decorating saucers with flowers. One year the Pilots bred white mice from a single pair and had plenty to sell.

*

For many years the White Elephant stall features the same tub of loose face powder, which was invariably purchased and then invariably donated back for resale the following year.

*

One man visited the fair late on Saturday afternoon. On the white elephant stall he found an ornament, and he bought it, thinking it would make a good pair to the one on the mantelpiece at home. His wife, who had always disliked the ornament and thought she had got rid of it, was not pleased.


*

CRICKET




To belong to the Williamstown Congregational Cricket Club, you needed to go to church twice a month. I went every week, but most went to two evening services. The minister used to organize a question and answer night when he knew the cricketers were coming. One night we asked him “Was Jonah really swallowed by a whale?” and “Are you pink? (a little bit communist?)” He said “Yes” and “No, I only have a mind of my own.” Like all Congregationalists.


*

Sir Dallas Brooks, the Governor of Victoria, attended worship for the 1956 church centenary. The cricketers took up the collection. They were told not to go to the governor in the front pew. They went there first. The aide-de-camp put an envelope into the plate. But they were chastised later by the minister.

*

TENNIS




I played in Wyclif’s tennis team from the age of 12; they had to get special permission. I remember standing outside our front gate in Florence Rd. I was still at school. Bob Holdaway arrived in his little grey Vauxhall to take us to an away match. When they got to me, the car already contained five adults. I would squeeze in.


Wyclif had two asphalt courts in Bona Vista Avenue, Surrey Hills, accessed by a narrow path. They had bumps caused by the roots of the surrounding poplar trees, a hut for a club-house, and permission to use the outside loo of the house next door. When Wyclif club folded, I went to Collins Street and timidly asked if I could come and play. It was 1954. Collins Street had 4 teams—a big club.

*

FANCY DRESS

One year I went as a bonbon, a Christmas cracker, a big orange-red one. I couldn’t sit down, and if I fell over, I was in strife. Another year I was a cricketer. Mum asked, ‘Who is she? Bradman or Keith Miller?’ We paraded around the hall. Then, when I was about eight and my sister about six, we went together as a bride and groom. She had a lacy shawl over her head. I had tails, a top hat and a cane. We had to walk around a circle while we were judged for prizes. One judge got the giggles, because I put on a limp.

*





Next: Chapter 6. Social Justice, Overseas and at Home

Back to index: Index